Volume 49, N. 2

Special Issue: COBRAMSEG 2024 (Invited Editors: V.P. Faro, B.P.A. Tonus), April-June 2026

The 10th James K. Mitchell Lecture - In situ and lab tests work together to reduce uncertainties in TSF fragility assessment: a benchmark case-history

Abstract

This article, a written contribution of the 10th James K. Mitchell, delivered in Bologna on June, 10, 2022, describes the experimental characterisation of Brumadinho B1 tailings dam, that allowed to study analytically a unique case history, of a massive earthwork which suddenly failed on January 25th of 2019 in Minas Gerais (Brazil). This detailed characterisation comprised an advanced experimental programme using reconstituted and undisturbed samples recoiled in three sampling campaigns in the remaining post-morten dam/reservoir tailings, where the failure mechanism developed. The results that embrace evaluations of the physical, hydraulic, and mechanical properties, allowed to define the geotechnical parameters necessary for the referred analyses. This cannot be completed without knowing how to deal with a heterogeneous distribution of types of tailings generated from distinct iron rock masses in the mine, which was pursued with re-interpretation of in situ tests, some recent with high quality data, clustering in zones that could be discretized by overall types of soils with proper index behaviour and state conditions. The necessary parameters for constitutive models based on Critical State Soil Mechanics with Instability Locus that could be used in stability numerical simulations, will be discussed – in their conditions - that can define a reliable back calculation of the failure.

Keywords: Advanced laboratory tests, Iron tailings, Critical state parameter, Brumadinho B1 dam failure, Instability, Liquefaction,


Submitted on July 29, 2025.
Final Acceptance on November 13, 2025.
Discussion open until August 31, 2026.
DOI: 10.28927/sr.2026.011425