Volume 49, N. 3

July-September 2026

Estimating soil water retention curve in tropical residual soils: a comparative study of measurement and modeling techniques

Abstract

This study evaluates various methods for estimating soil water retention curves (SWRCs) in tropical residual soils from the Baixada Santista region, Brazil, including both young and mature profiles. Laboratory data were obtained using HYPROP, WP4C, and the filter paper method, and curve fitting was performed using unimodal and bimodal van Genuchten models. The estimates were derived from mercury intrusion porosimetry (MIP), pedotransfer functions (PTF-SV and PTF-Bi), and inverse modeling with Hydrus-1D, using field moisture and rainfall data from CEMADEN. Model performance was assessed using RMSE, MAE, MBE, and correlation coefficients. For mature soils, PTF-SV showed the best statistical performance but failed to represent bimodal structure. In contrast, PTF-Bi and MIP better reflected dual porosity but with higher errors. For young soils, Hydrus-1D produced the best fit, especially in simpler pore systems. Although the models showed a strong correlation with laboratory data, they often yielded divergent van Genuchten parameters, indicating that statistical agreement does not necessarily ensure an accurate physical representation. No method consistently outperformed others across all soil types. These findings highlight the influence of soil structure and calibration data on model reliability and reinforce the need to develop tailored approaches for Brazilian tropical soils with complex hydraulic behavior.

Keywords: Residual soils, Laboratory tests, Inverse modeling, Mercury intrusion porosimetry, Pedotransfer functions, Dual porosity,


Submitted on October 22, 2025.
Final Acceptance on March 31, 2026.
Discussion open until November 30, 2026.
DOI: 10.28927/sr.2026.017425